Better at playing Evil Jared Padalecki or Tom Welling?

[Davis Bloome]

Neither are really evil imo. But when Clark is on red K, it's a hell more funny than with Sam, so that's why I voted for him.

[Rosslyn]

Jared. He is so much better playing evil than good, that it's amazing to me. He's like David Boreanaz in this way.

[xrayvision]

Damn I dont know! TW is a great actor and has had more practice at it..but Jared not having much did an amazing job. My vote goes to Jared..he was just pure evil. And like Smallvillerocks45 stated above..hes never really evil..just a badass.

Amazing how so many back then found it hard to choose. I thought back then in Born Under A Bad Sign that Jared was quite a bit better, but after looking through the years like last season and his performance as Lucifer in The End, he is much better at playing an evil character.

[Davis Bloome]

He didn't even come off as evil in The End. Intimidating yes, but the way he spoke about God... That was not much evil... More like love, real love, which could have pushed Lucifer to become evil, but the only thing I traced of evil is how he broke Dean 2014's neck.

[Syn]

When TW was playing Bizarro; pretty damn evil.

[WillyWilson]

I've never really watched Supernatural, nothing against it, just never got into it. I think both Jared and Tom are good actors. I voted for Tom, because he's my #1.

[JusticeDC]

JARED hello...its jared comeon he is sammy ....

[Daddylion]

And Satan... Satan + Jared = SEXY!!

[Sugar]

Jared

[luisl]

This poll is a joke right? Tom Welling sucks at acting really...

[readhead]

I like both actors but after seeing Tom Welling as Clark Luthor (evil clark from another world) i have to vote for him

[kalel1938]

I like both actors but after seeing Tom Welling as Clark Luthor (evil clark from another world) i have to vote for him

agree 100% i thought he could really be evil after bizzaro and they let him prove me right.

[Anno_Domini]

1.) Samifer
2.) Kal
3.) Clark Luthor
4.) Meg!Sam

[ryro-fanfiction-x3]

I liked Tom Welling as Clark Luthor, that was a great perfomance from him.