Well, I don't understand several of your choices for top ten. I thought "Eternal" was pretty much a load of garbage and I thought "Beast" was also a horrible episode and the start of a terrible downward spiral on the show where Clark's viewpoint was downplayed so that others could be built up as the heroes over him. That's why this is subjective.
I totally understand why "Stiletto" is on some people's list. It's on mine. Clark was written very well in the episode. His viewpoint was validated and he was the hero of the episode. Lois made some mistakes in the episode but she was called on those mistakes and showed character growth. (What a novel concept on this show!) Clark made a selfless choice to throw himself in front of the bullet at the end of the episode and came out the hero. The ending scene at the Daily Planet was loaded with chemistry and spoke to the changing feelings between Lois and Clar and the final scene of the episode between Lois and The Red-Blue-Blur was a true Superman moment. Clark was Superman in that moment and it was a turning point in his relationship with Lois.
Ironically, one of the reviewers for the Superman homepage despised pretty much the entire second half of SEason 8---except for "Stiletto." It was one of the only episodes that he gave a good review to in the second half of the season.
This is all subjective. For me, it all comes down to writing for CLARK. If Clark is written well and written as a leader than the episode is a huge success to me. "Stiletto" did that.
I totally understand why "Stiletto" is on some people's list. It's on mine. Clark was written very well in the episode. His viewpoint was validated and he was the hero of the episode. Lois made some mistakes in the episode but she was called on those mistakes and showed character growth. (What a novel concept on this show!) Clark made a selfless choice to throw himself in front of the bullet at the end of the episode and came out the hero. The ending scene at the Daily Planet was loaded with chemistry and spoke to the changing feelings between Lois and Clar and the final scene of the episode between Lois and The Red-Blue-Blur was a true Superman moment. Clark was Superman in that moment and it was a turning point in his relationship with Lois.
Ironically, one of the reviewers for the Superman homepage despised pretty much the entire second half of SEason 8---except for "Stiletto." It was one of the only episodes that he gave a good review to in the second half of the season.
This is all subjective. For me, it all comes down to writing for CLARK. If Clark is written well and written as a leader than the episode is a huge success to me. "Stiletto" did that.
Comment